Skip to main content

Advice for young career focused folk based on "choosing between poverty and debt"


Have read an ambiguous article today about "Young People in the UK to Choose Between Poverty and Debt".

What is apparent, there are socio-economical issues that the UK people would like to resolve:
  • growing unemployment
  • growing poverty
  • young people sitting on welfare payments
  • competition from skilled people from other countries

The initiative David Cameron announced sounds very interesting, especially in it's part where jobless "would have to accept mandatory 'community work'" if failing to find employment within reasonable timeframe.

I would like to highlight some failing points in the article that are presenting the initiative as "predictably vindictive" and with permission from a reader to provide advice to "young" persons like me.

One of the complaints is low level of payment for apprenticeship and for young men and women who just finished studies. This claim is based on presumption that every business owner (and in modern world everything is "considered" as a business even a government) should pay as much as required by the person who is seeking apprenticeship or a newly graduate. Meaning a person in 99.9% of cases with zero or very limited experience in any industry and in life generally.
Imagine you run basket weaving business. Leaving the issue of sales and other business related problems you are suggested to pay high salary to an apprentice or a recent graduate who doesn't know how to weave properly, doesn't know all your product designs, very slow (because of no skills), keeps asking questions and make mistakes here and there. Also if you have a contract to make a deliver a batch of baskets for certain deadline and of certain quality that you charge for - you would need to make sure the apprentice is covered by somebody more experienced and that person wouldn't be very happy to work more in prevailing majority of cases without immediate increase in remuneration.

People who distribute money to others and can control this process are deciding what to do with it. Therefore complaints about minimal payments are just useless. In addition to that there is a passage "History offers something of a solution then — falling poverty through rising wages and state funding for those who choose learning", which is not followed by the explanation of where to get the money to rise wages? In the past it has been easy with refinancing - meaning that countries could grow debt or other means to boost their internal economy the results of which was invested in welfare, wages, infrastructure etc. Now "The Times They Are a-Changin'"

Second problem I see in the article is an appeal to some guarantee of earnings - "while doing nothing to guarantee earnings that are worth turning up for". Everybody who is currently leaving on planet Earth and is a human being should understand that there is no guarantee of earnings! Can businesses (including government) get money to feed people working for them - there are earnings. That means every person who is willing to feel comfortable with earnings should be flexible and learn as much about the world as possible and work harder every day. "Being smarter" is getting negative connotation these days, because too many people showing off as being "smart" and take advantage of others. Therefore not everybody can be smarter, but everybody can and should work harder. Labour played a good deal in the transition from ape to man a long time ago and therefore labour makes us better. All labour that is value adding and that is available to us in the modern world.

I have been a student myself (almost 15 years ago I finished university) and I understand the issues that the young adults are facing, but the key is to understand that people who provide working places and create opportunities also would like a reward for that. This is alright and natural and there is no foreseeable easy solutions for this conflict of interests.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Wine - 2011 Brown Brothers Crouchen Riesling

Very nice wine with fruity taste - peach and pear: Consumed with Hungarian salami. Tasting notes .
Post a Comment
Read more

Scrum - Team Culture and Wall Manifesto

In the Scrum framework one of the key components is the wall and daily stand-up. In some organisations I worked with the whole concept of the wall is not accepted by many developers, because of the stand-up necessity and "time waste". Very often all that methodology is used for the sake of methodology and not to achieve what we actually do - adding or creating value to our customer (usually called "The Business"). I can understand frustration that is caused by the wall and stand-up process. From the software developer perspective it is really a waste of time for the following reasons: 1. In 95% of cases developers are head down working like hell delivering valuable outcomes that they are accountable for. Extra effort to go to the wall, staying there for 15-30 minutes and listening or not listening to what others were doing yesterday and will be doing tomorrow is annoying for them; 2. The mere fact of having to do something mandatory to do that looks like...
Post a Comment
Read more

Mastering The Multitasking

There is usually two distinct perspectives on multi-tasking: 1. Multitasking is counterproductive. We get distracted by multiple tasks that all get our way and fight for our scarce attention, time and resources. This leads to a common fallacy that if you do multiple activities “at a time” you are not doing good work in any of those. 2. Multitasking is a way of getting many things done in a short period of time or in a long run. Indeed it can be either a disaster or a great helper depending on how it is used and practiced. Most recent research shows that we don’t do multiple tasks purely in parallel or simultaneously. That means we don’t purely multi-task, but switch between tasks and execute them one at a time, but by spending very small timeframes on each task. A good example from the history is a story about Julius Caesar capabilities in that area. Plutarch writes, “Caesar disciplined himself so far as to be able to dictate letters from on horseback, and to give directi...
1 comment
Read more