Skip to main content

Documentary "Four Horsemen" - Review

Have recently watched "Four Horsemen" - documentary on current global economic issues. It was interesting, because I have recently read a book Confessions of an Economic Hit Man by John Perkins who is also featured in the documentary.

What I found is that though the general idea towards "greater good" is natural, the ways how issues are explained in the movie and the reasons and solutions that are briefly outlined are not consistent sometimes with either logic or obvious observations.

33:00 - The narrator states that the inflow of lending money into the housing market led to an unprecedent inflation. "House prices rose and rose."
This completely satisfies the classical economic theory that guys just praised a bit earlier in the video.
Because interest rates were low and people borrowed more and more to buy properties.
But is it not because there is always a demand for property? People have to live somewhere.

At 33:40 Prof. Simon Johnson (former IMF Chief Economist) was saying that in Germany people are ok to rent without owning the property and be perfectly comfortable.
But there is a difference between paying rent and paying a mortgage.
Rent is just paying money to somebody forever without generating any possession for yourself and therefore being always dependent on a landlord's will.
Mortgage at least allows individuals to secure properties for themselves or for their family at least.
That's natural and completely fit into the classic economic theory. However the Professor states that when people want to own a property (which is a necessity, isn't it?) it is not right.

By the way, neoclassical economics worked well in some countries where government controlled economy and where everybody could receive a place to live.
The size of the lot was depending on the family or other social circumstances and merit, but everybody could get a place.

Also I just can't see how deregulation say in property market will help people acquire properties?

45:50 - "we have to tolerate inequality..." says Lord Griffiths (former vice chairman of Goldman Sachs) - well physical inequality or inequality at birth - no problems. But when inequality becomes an everlasting system of increasing wealth for some and eternal race for the wage to the rest of the world - it shouldn't be tolerated.

1:10:16 - Phillip Blond (Director of ResPublica), raised concerns that we have less relationships and marriages. When today's goal is to earn more money - all relationships especially ones with higher financial responsibility (marriage and children) are excluded.
All natural. Again later he says that money is not the main thing that matter to us. But he has possibly forgotten that all necessities in our life require money! Property or a rental place, food, education, electricity, transportation, health insurance etc. all these things have enormous cost at the moment.
If you add family and children here - how could you imagine living without money?

1:21:00 - Dr. Michael Hudson (Government Policy Adviser) has provided a good example of debt clearing in 1947 in Germany. This is a brilliant idea. Especially to those who currently hold mortgages or other form of huge debt (education, medical etc.)


Popular posts from this blog

Energy Business Case - Coal Mine in West Virginia

Situation Coal in Africa: An opportunity is available to invest in a coal mine in West Virginia. The mine’s value is less than in past years because of actual and anticipated restrictions on coal-fired power generation in the United States. However, the mine has a chance to sell its coal on contract to a public utility in West Africa. The utility is working through the World Bank for financing to build a number of coal-fired power plants. If they obtain World Bank financing, then a customer for the coal mine is assured, at least for the duration of the contracts. The power plants will employ the best current technology for burning coal, which exceeds all current air quality standards for the region. However, the power plants will not be designed to attempt carbon capture. The area of Africa the plants will serve suffers from extreme energy poverty, with some of the lowest per capita energy consumption in the world.

Overview of the Region West Africa is the westernmost region …

Energy Market Analysis - Coal Reserves for Decade Ending 2012 and Price Forecast

According to the British Petroleum Statistical Review of World Energy, 2013, global coal reserves declined in the decade ending 2012:

Figure 1. Proved coal reserves.

Proved reserves of coal are generally taken to be those quantities that geological and engineering information indicates with reasonable certainly can be recovered in the future from known deposits under existing economic and operating conditions.

If we look at supply and demand factors in the decline, we can see that:

a) Coal price has grown significantly in the decade ending 20121:

  Figure 2. Prices in US Dollars per tonne.

b) Coal consumption has also grown significantly worldwide2:

Figure 3. Coal consumption by region.

c) The price of substitutes (i.e. Natural Gas) has also grown. Not so in North America though, but if we look at the world trend it is growing3:

Figure 4. Natural gas prices.

Therefore if the rule of supply and demand worked we would see increase in proved reserves for coal, because increase in dem…

Wine - Castello del Poggio Moscato Provincia di Pavia

Awesome wine. Sweet with notes of pear, caramel, apricot.

Some details